• roundup5381@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      2 months ago

      eh, don’t be. Even though passenger rail legally has right of way, in practice they often get stuck behind freight, in the worst cases of my experience, leading to several hours of delay.

      wish that the law would be enforced but that hasn’t been the case for decades, if ever.

      • AA5B@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        5
        ·
        2 months ago

        That’s just an argument that we need to find rail sufficiently for Amtrak to own its rails. Freight is never in the way on the NEC.

        It’s also an indictment for lack of regulation. Freight rail has been milking ancient infrastructure far beyond its useful life and without updating to new requirements.

        Among their shortcuts that directly cause delays for both trains and cars are

        • failure to maintain tracks to keep the speed they were designed for
        • pulling up second rail for cheaper maintenance
        • continuing to run ever larger trains without enlarging the sidings that are supposed to let them get out of the way
          • AA5B@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            2 months ago

            That’s from a couple years ago, and there was a recent one connected with that proposal. I know what you mean.

            While I somewhat agree with the desire to facilitate this private passenger rail service, it seems like a really bad idea here and now. Maybe if we had healthy infrastructure and widely adopted service, that could take us to the next level, but passenger rail in the us is such a basket case that it would not serve anyone’s needs.

            • no matter what, we have a century of deferred maintenance to catch up on. No private company could afford that and we shouldn’t spend that kind of money just so someone can extract profit
            • no matter what, outside the NEC, intercity passenger service is horrible: it’s a welfare case now, is not in a useful state, and we shouldn’t be paying that kind of money just so someone can extract profit
            • highways are supported by public funding: intercity passenger rail deserves similar. We need options where either s better than the other

            While part of me wishes we could keep NEC profit to invest in all the improvements we need here, I generally think it’s a good investment to try to develop other locations. Transportation infrastructure is a public good to improve our society and our economy (and the network effect is a big deal), but taking some of our NEC profit to pay for some billionaires profit is very much NOT a public good